Ah! Guilty as charged
That we now find ourselves required to discuss and investigate care specifically, and can no longer get by simply speaking of the more general prophetic call, can only mean that care (And thus also Christianity) has already become something other than what it should be. This is why we should try very hard not to talk of care, or at least not care in and of itself.
Whew! Let me try to unpack all this a little better with an example. A friend of imine who is Maori recently noted that many pakeha Christians now seem constantly to talk about community, whereas Maori rarely do. Without wanting to take this too far, it would seem that for many Maori community is pretty much self-evident, or presumed, and thus doesn’t require much discussion. In contrast, for most pakeha Christians community is talked about constantly, but is rarely actually apparent. This act of speaking about community, then, this invocation of the latent promise within language, is an attempt to speak into being something that is absent. Language here becomes an attempt to come to terms with something that remains elusive, remain difficult even to conceptualise and formulate. Given all this it might be useful to consider the amount we must speak as a measure of how we we are actually doing, or, more precisely, the extent to which we have actually internalised the spoken, whether it be community or care. When we need to discuss something specificaly, in order to try and bring it into being, then there is an acknowledgment of its absence. Moreover, the act of speaking of something also puts it forward as only an option. So long as we speak specifically about community or care, soa s to bring them into being, we also acknowledge the absence, and therefore their contingent or optional character …
[from Mike Mawson’s article “Why I try not to care (and I don’t want to talk about it)” in the August 2003 edition of Stimulus]
5 responses to “Ah! Guilty as charged”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
This contribution reminds me of that line of Eliot’s “Teach me to care and not to care, teach me to sit still …” Does anyone remember it’s ending? I have a ghost of the sense of it in my memory, but don’t dare try for fear of corrupting those last few words. “Care” is also a chief motif in James Olthuis’ very valuale book, The Beautiful Risk, an attempt at wrinting an advisory to Christian psychotherapists who asked him to do so.
A fuller quotation of the poem
The two lines that follow “… teach me to sit still” are:
Pray for us sinners now and at the hour of our death
Pray for us now and at the hour of our death.
….soon replies: “God doth not need either man’s work or his own gifts: who best bear his mild yoke, they serve him best. His state is kingly; thousands at his bidding speed and post o’er land and ocean without rest: they also serve who only stand and wait.”
— John Milton
..who only stand and wait. Sometimes the most difficult of all